ההשקפה החב"דית באספקלריית דברי ימי אדמור"י וחסידי חב"ד לדורותיהם

Sunday, May 23, 2010

The Rebbe - The Berlin-Paris Years

There has recently been a renewed interest in the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s activities and lifestyle during the period that he spent in Berlin and Paris between the years 1927-1940.

Apparently there has been some speculation "that [the future Rebbe] Menachem Schneerson… was never completely engaged by his chasidic upbringing, preferring instead the modernizing and secularizing influences that made such significant inroads among young Jewish intellectuals in early 20th-century Russia and Europe." As evidence they point to the fact that he chose “to trim his beard, wear modern suits, and distance himself from the chasidic community in Paris, where he and his wife, the daughter of the previous Lubavitcher Rebbe, lived after their marriage.”

I will not dispute the assertion that, though “there is no question he was an observant Jew... he lived in places where Chasidim didn’t live, and he did things they wouldn’t do.” Another point that I won’t dispute is that the Rebbe may never have thought of himself as a candidate for the position of Rebbe. However, if this is to lend credence to the author’s claim that the Rebbe veered away from the path of his forbearers and father-in-law and essentially lived the life of a modern orthodox Jew rather than that of a Chassidic Jew, the authors must have ignored a large swath of readily available information, which conclusively proves this thesis to be incorrect. While no one will argue that the Rebbe dressed like a Chossid during his years in Berlin and Paris, there is no doubt that he remained a Chossid in every sense of the word and was absolutely committed to the service of his revered father-in-law, the Previous Lubavitcher Rebbe, as we will demonstrate.


The first and the most accessible proof that the Rebbe remained a fully committed Chossid, despite his external appearance, are the many video interviews conducted with people who relate first-hand testimony of people who knew him personally during this period. Below is the content of some of these interviews which you can watch yourselves. [Although the interviews were conducted by Chabad, the interviewees themselves are generally not Chabad, and there is no reason to suspect them of bias.]

See here for the account by Rabbi Fabian Schonfeld, president of the RCA and student of Rabbi J. B. Solivietchik (“the Rav”) for approximately fifty years, of the Rav’s testimony that the Rebbe “never missed going to the Mikvah, a single day during the time he was in Berlin”. The Rav’s exact words were, “Ich ken mei’id zein, az er hot nisht farfelt kein ein tog Mikveh”.

See here were Rabbi Yechezkel Besser recalls the testimony of Reb Yitzchok Meir Ferstenberg, described as “a critic” from whom “one rarely heard… praise about someone”. Regarding the Rebbe, however, “he was full of praise”. He testified that “the Rebbe never changed”, he always wore a hat or a beret, and never went without a head covering, despite the fact that this sometimes clashed with the social conformity of the times. Regarding the discussion relating to the Rebbe’s beard he testified, “He had a beard, uncut, untouched”. Rabbi Besser goes on to say that these are only trivial examples, which fail to do justice to the true greatness that Ferstenburg discerned in the Rebbe’s personality.

Another interesting episode he related: when the Belzer Rebbe, the Kedushas Ahron visited Berlin for medical reasons, Ferstenburg accompanied the Rebbe to visit the Belzer Rebbe. The Belzer Rebbe stood with closed eyes with his hand wrapped in a towel and shook people’s hands through the towel. However when the Rebbe came, he picked up his eyes and took of the towel, giving him his bare hand.

[Regarding the issue of the Rebbe’s beard, this has already been discussed here and here. The testimony quoted in the first source that refers to the Rebbe as “the rather modern-dressed young man with the neatly trimmed beard who stood at the back of the shiur room and who would talk in learning after almost every shiur with Rav Yechiel Yaakov Weinberg z"l” can be dismissed as a statement based on the general impression made on the mind of someone who did not know the Rebbe well and merely observed him from afar or at best had a very casual relationship with him. Obviously such testimony doesn’t stand up against that of people who shared a close relationship with him, especially considering the many other sources (brought above and below) which inform us of his staunch adherence to the Chassid way of life in all other areas. Also see the letter dated 21 adar-1 5592 (1932), written by the Rebbe to his father-in-law “…it is clear that he [the Tzemach Tzedek] holds that even with scissors it is forbidden (even those that are not “like a razor”), and not only due to [the prohibition of] Lo Silbash Gever…”. (Igres Kodesh Vol. 1 page 2.)]

See here where Rabbi Sholom Kovalski recalls the Rav’s testimony that the Rebbe fasted Ba’hab during his time in Berlin, but due to the Rebbe’s tremendous humility the Rav only became aware of it by chance. “He was extremely quiet; very few people knew who he was or where he came from.” It would seem, in fact, that this entire misconception that the Rebbe veered away from the Chassidic way of life, is a direct result of the Rebbe deliberately attempting to hide his true nature from the world. [There is also a published letter from the Rebbe’s father, in which he begs his son to desist from fasting.]

Some of the many other video testimonials regarding this period have been collected here, in which the Rebbe’s commitment, not only to his own observance of Yidishkeit, but also to the support and furtherance of Yiddishkeit in general, is described in detail. As an aside, the beginnings of his tremendous efforts to further Jewish education in America can be seen in his activates during his time in Paris, where he taught a daily Gemorah Shuir and established Torah classes for Jewish children.


Additionally, and perhaps more importantly, the Rebbe’s personal journals from this period have been published, filling five volumes mainly with Chudishim ranging across Kabbalah, Gemorah, Chassidus and Halacha, in a brilliant display of broad knowledge and incisive depth(they are available on hebrewbooks.org, the first volume is here). Reshimos HaMenorah written in 5699 (1939), fills a separate volume and deals with “the [variant] opinions regarding the order of the lighting of the Menorah in the Temple and their reasoning’s, and the significance according to Drush founded on the explanations in Chassidus”. This large body of published information combined with the Rebbe’s published letters, and those which his father wrote to him provide ample evidence of the tremendous degree to which he was steeped in Torah learning and Chassidic thought even as he attended the lectures of the secular professors in the universities of Europe. Ignorance of this gold mine, which opens a broad window of invaluable insight into exactly what was preoccupying the Rebbe’s mind during the period under discussion, equals an automatic disqualification from passing comment on the Rebbe's inner life.

Even a cursory glance at some of this material shows that apart from being “completely engaged by his chasidic upbringing”, the concept of Moshiach was already high up in the Rebbe’s area of interest.
This refutes the suggestion that Moshiach was an idea that gradually developed after the Rebbe decided to pursue “a new career goal”, indeed on his 54th birthday in 1956 the Rebbe himself wrote in a letter that “From the time that I was a child attending cheder, and even before, there began to take form in my mind a picture of the future redemption -- the redemption of Israel from its last exile, a redemption such as would explicate the suffering, the decrees and the massacres of the galut...” The fundamentals which he absorbed as young child, which he was educated in by his father and the Chassidic Melamdim who taught him, remained with him throughout his life and were in no way eroded during the time he spent in the “modern” atmosphere of Berlin and Paris.

Let us not overlook too the active connection, which the Rebbe kept up with his father-in-law during this period. Even when he was physically separated from his father-in-law they remained in constant communication, and the Rebbe continued to work on various projects on his father-in-laws behalf. Notably, the Rebbe acted as an editor for the periodical “Hatomim”, sorting through the many letters penned by his father-in-law, copies of which were forwarded to Berlin and later Paris, and selecting for publication those that were relevant to Chassidim in general as well there original recipients. The Rebbe’s work in this area is detailed in the introduction to the Igros Kodesh of the Friediker Rebbe Vol. 3. Another example of a more specific project which the Friediker Rebbe charged his son-in-law with, is the writing of Reshimas HaMenorah as described above.

As evidenced from the Reshimos and other sources the Friediker Rebbe was present in Berlin together with his son-in-law at the beginning of Av 5690 (1930) [where he stopped on his back to Riga after his trip to America]. The Rebbe traveled to Riga to spend the entire Tishrei 5691 [1930] with his father-in-law, and again before the festival of Pesach of the same year [1931] staying till after Shavuos. He was again together with his father-in-law for Tishrei 5692, which was spent in Otvotzk, a suburb of Warsaw, where the main branch of Yeshivas Toimchei Temimim had been established, returning to Riga together with him where he stayed till the end of Cheshvan before traveling back to Berlin. He returned to Riga for Pesach and remained together with his father-in-law through the Marriage of his sister-in-law Shaineh, after Shavuos, after which he accompanied him to Poland, where they remained for much of the Summer before returning to Riga for Tishrei 5693 [1932] where he remained till after Chanukah...

I won’t bore you with too many details, but suffice it to say that the Rebbe spent large parts of the year away from Berlin and Paris, in order to be in the company of his father-in-law, and was visited in turn by the Friediker Rebbe in those cities. As is clear from his personal journals, the Rebbe relished these opportunities and meticulously recorded everything he heard and saw, his deep interest in Chassidic customs and stories is self evident. These are not the journals of a “westernized / modernized thinker” but the journals of a Chossid deeply attached to his Chassidic roots and his Rebbe, and constantly preoccupied with the infinite truth of G-d’s Torah.

Did the Rebbe want to become an engineer? Perhaps. Did he view that as his goal in life? Ciratinly not. Did he veer away from the Chassidic path only to return after accepting “the undeniable facts that he was a forty-something immigrant with little English and less chance of making significant inroads as a successful secular professional.” Whereupon “he reluctantly accepted that a career as a chasidic Rebbe would have to do”? Certainly not. It is clear from the information available that the Rebbe was completely committed to the Chassidic ideal, revered his father-in-law and followed his every directive unquestioningly. A mere glance at the relevant sources reveals that at every step of the way, the Rebbe was a servant who did what had to be done conscientiously and quietly, serving G-d with complete selflessness, while trying to keep as low a profile as possible. Reluctant though he was, when his father-in-law passed away, he did not shirk the responsibility thrust on him, and accepting the demands of the Chassidim led them with unparalleled self-sacrifice to confront the new challenges faced by post-holocaust American Jewry.


  1. The Belzer would give his hand to much less prestigous people. Read the new book from the eynekel of Moreynu Rosenheim; Reb Ahron Belzer was blind and still picked him out of a crowd and gave him a direct handshake.

    BTW, Reb Chatzkel Besser was biased. His son became a fervent Lubavitcher and he was in awe of the Rebbe.

    Whether the Rebbe trimmed his beard or went to the mikva or not, is irrelevant. The question is why he went to study engineering at all and sat in mixed classes. Additionaly, where is the record that the University was overlly impressed with the Rebbe's genios, personlity and charisma?

    The other main point of the book, that the Rebbe didn't plan on a carrer in the rebistive you did not refute. How do you know that it isn't true that, at that point of time, he thought the Rashag would take over? Aderabe, you can say that that is greater tesimoney of the Rebbe's greatness; even though he wasn't planning for a public career, he still was a loyal chossid.

  2. 1) I never claimed that "the University was overlly impressed with the Rebbe's genios, personlity and charisma".

    2)"That the Rebbe didn't plan on a carrer in the rebistive you did not refute" - nor did I try to. It may very well be that he never intended to become Rebbe.

    3) The main issue that I am pointing out is that from the Rebbe's personal journals as well as the correspondence and testimony available it is clear to the unbiased eye that though the Rebbe did not live the external life of a Chossid and shunned publicity of any kind, internally he remained a committed Chossid of his father-in-law, steeped in Chassidus, Torah scholarship and piety.

  3. check this out:

  4. Thanks anonymous at 7:22am, btw I already linked to that page in the post above.

  5. "The Belzer Rebbe stood with closed eyes with his hand wrapped in a towel and shook people’s hands through the towel."

    Can you explain why this was?

  6. I cant explain this with any certainty, but I would suggest that this had to do with the fact that he was a Tzadik. Perhaps there had to be some kind separation between his purity and holiness, and the coarse impurity of the simple folk who came to visit him. Whether was to protect himself from their coarseness or to protect them from his holiness, he choose to interact with them and allow them to attach themselves to the Tzadik via a shield.
    This is perhaps reminiscent of the saying of our sages to the effect that when Moshiach comes G-d will take the sun out from its sheild, Reshoim to be punished with it and Tzadikim to be rewarded with it.

  7. The Sidrei Aish was once conversing with R' Dovid Hollander A"H, andwhen the subject of the American Gedolim came up, the Sidrei Aish said "I know the Gedolim from your country(refering to the Rebbe, Rabbi JB Soleveitchik, and R' Yitzchok Hutner), because they were my Talmidim in Berlin, but the only one who emerged from Berlin unscathed was the Lubvaitcher Rebbe

  8. Re;the beard issue.

    R' Itche Meir and another Gerer Chossid testifyied that the Rebbe guardedhis beard, and you could see that although it may have been rolled up at some times, you could see how carefull he was.

  9. I find it interesting that the authors don't mention the many correspondences between the Rebbe and the Rogatchover Goan during those years and even prior to his marriage. There are several other examples of omissions that come to mind as well.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...